Day Pitney successfully represented a developer in overturning a zoning board's denial of its use variance and density variance application, which sought to develop a townhome development in a single-family residential zone. The case, decided in New Jersey Superior Court, Law Division, was Ferris Farms of East Brunswick LLC v. East Brunswick Zoning Board of Adjustment. The trial court agreed that the applicant had presented overwhelming expert testimony in support of the use variance and density variance, none of which was contradicted by other experts, including the Board's experts. The team represented Ferris Farms of East Brunswick, LLC and was led by Day Pitney Real Estate Partner Craig M. Gianetti with the assistance of Associate Amanda M. Kronemeyer.
"This victory demonstrates the importance of creating a robust record in support of a variance application before a local board. It is also a caution for local boards that a denial that is rendered in spite of credible, uncontroverted expert testimony is ripe for challenge," Gianetti noted.
The case arose out of the developer's bifurcated use variance and density variance application on the now-closed Ferris Farms nursery in East Brunswick. The property is located in the R-1 single-family residential zone, which permitted one-acre lots. The developer proposed to remove the nonconforming nursery and develop a multifamily townhouse development in the single-family residential zone.
Contrary to a traditional use variance application, the application was proposing a residential use in a residential zone. The type of residential unit type was not permitted (townhomes as opposed to single-family homes). As a result, the developer also required a density variance for seeking more total units than permitted in the zone. The applicant originally proposed a 50-unit townhouse development, but over the course of several hearings on the application, the developer amended the application to reduce the development to 36 townhouses and then to 30 townhouses.
The court agreed with the developer that the Zoning Board's decision denying the requested use and density variances was arbitrary, capricious, and unreasonable, and not based upon substantial evidence in the record. The developer presented expert testimony from a civil engineer, professional planner, traffic engineer, and real estate expert. No contradictory expert testimony was presented by the Board professionals or objectors. In fact, the Board professionals even acknowledged some of the points raised by the developer's experts.
The 43-page decision was rendered by Judge McCloskey in the Middlesex County Law Division. This decision comes on the heels of the Appellate Division affirming a recent decision by Judge McCloskey in 15 High Street, LLC v. Boro. of Helmetta Planning Board (2022 WL 710788), holding that a board must base its rejection of an applicant's expert testimony "on contrary expert testimony rather than bare allegations or unsubstantiated beliefs." Read Day Pitney's Alert on the decision here.
Day Pitney Real Estate Partner Steven J. Wernick is featured in RentCafe article "Unlocking Miami-Dade's Housing Potential."
Day Pitney Real Estate Partner Steven J. Wernick is featured in the South Florida Business Journal article "28-Story Tower With Over 100 Apartments Planned in Miami."
Day Pitney Alert
Day Pitney Real Estate, Environmental and Land Use practice co-chair Craig Gianetti was featured in Gothamist article "Court Tells Wealthy NJ Town: We'll Decide Where You'll Put Affordable Housing."
Day Pitney Press Release
Day Pitney Real Estate, Environmental and Land Use Partner Steven Wernick is featured in the Miami Herald article "The End of Single-Family-Only Home Suburbs? Miami-Dade Zoning Rule Impact Could Be 'Sweeping'."
Day Pitney Real Estate Partners Nicole Magdziak and Thomas Malman represented firm client Kushner, a real estate development and management firm headquartered in New York City, on a multimillion dollar mixed use residential and retail development in the Long Branch, NJ’s Lower Broadway redevelopment zone.
Day Pitney Real Estate, Environmental and Land Use practice co-chair Craig Gianetti was featured in Law360 article "NJ Bill Paves An Aggressive Affordable-Housing Path."
Day Pitney Real Estate, Environmental and Land Use Counsel Joseph A. Ruiz was featured in the South Florida Business Journal article "Local Distillery Proposes Location in Miami-Dade Warehouse."
Day Pitney Alert
Copyright © 2024 Day Pitney LLP, all rights reserved.