Skip to Main Content

Insights

Thought Leadership

Publisher: Automotive News
September 29, 2026

Guest commentary: ​Florida case will decide if linking vehicle allocations to facility upgrades constitutes coercion

Additional vehicles, cash payments, and other benefits can encourage dealers to participate in manufacturer facility-upgrade programs. But when declining to participate puts a dealer at a significant competitive disadvantage, the line between incentive and coercion becomes less clear.

In an article for Automotive News, Day Pitney Partners Laurence Smith and Michael Fialkoff examine that divide through The Collection, LLC v. Porsche Latin America, Inc., a notable Florida case involving a Porsche program that conditioned eligibility for discretionary vehicle allocations on facility upgrades. They explore whether the program offered dealers a permissible incentive or effectively penalized those that chose not to participate, as well as how the outcome could help courts evaluate similar disputes under state dealer-protection laws.

Read more here.

Related Practices and Industries

Authors

Laurence M. Smith
Laurence M. Smith
Partner
Parsippany, NJ
| (973) 966-8128
Michael L. Fialkoff
Michael L. Fialkoff
Partner
Parsippany, NJ
| (973) 966-8139

Explore Day Pitney's latest media mentions and speaking appearances.

Press Contact

Elyse Blazey Gentile
Director of Communications

EMAIL DISCLAIMER

Thank you for your interest in contacting us by email.

Your e-mail to this individual should not contain any confidential information and should be for general information purposes only. An attorney-client relationship will not be created by your e-mail to this individual. Information in your e-mail may not be entitled to any protections commonly associated with communications with attorneys. If you are in doubt about any information, please exclude it.

If you accept the terms of this notice and would like to send an email, click on the "I Agree" button below. Otherwise, please click "I Don't Agree".