Real property tax uncertainty remains for New Jersey not-for-profit hospitals in the wake of Gov. Christie's pocket veto of S3299/A4903 (the Bill). The Bill was the New Jersey Legislature's response to the New Jersey Tax Court's decision this past year in AHS Hospital Corp., d/b/a Morristown Memorial Hospital v. Towns of Morristown, 28 N.J. 456 (Tax Ct. 2015).1 The Bill would have required the owner of an acute care not-for-profit hospital to make an annual "community service contribution" to the municipality where the hospital was located based on a formula of "$2.50 a day for each licensed bed" in the hospital in the prior tax year. The annual community service contribution for a satellite emergency care facility was $250 per day.
According to the Senate Budget and Appropriations Committee Report:
[T]his bill maintains the property tax exempt status of a nonprofit hospital with for-profit medical providers on site as long as the hospital remains organized as a nonprofit institution under State law, and requires nonprofit hospitals to, in lieu of property taxes, pay an annual community service contribution to their host municipalities. The clarified property tax exemption under the bill extends to the portions of hospital property used for medical purposes, and the community service contributions are required to be used to offset the costs of public safety services, such as police and fire safety services, or to reduce the property tax levy.
The Bill also would have allowed an owner "required to remit the community service contribution" to apply to the New Jersey Health Care Facilities Financing Authority for a certificate exempting the owner from the payment of the community service contribution if the owner was "in financial distress or at risk of being in financial distress." The Bill did not define "financial distress."
With no legislative guidance, many uncertainties (and likely additional costs for legal and other expert valuation services) remain for both not-for-profit hospitals and municipalities. All parties will be looking to assert and defend their positions regarding the extent of the applicable exemption as well as the valuation and assessment of the nonexempt portions of the hospitals' properties. Indeed, the examination of whether a hospital is tax-exempt will continue to be an analysis based on the factual circumstances of how each hospital is organized and conducts its operations.
[1] See Day Pitney Alert, New Jersey Tax Court Invalidates Hospital's Tax Exemption, June 29, 2015.
Day Pitney Litigation Partner Stephen Catanzaro and Litigation Associate Erin Hodgson authored the article "Appellate Division Rejects Objectors' Attempt to Challenge Development Approvals," for the New Jersey Law Journal.
Day Pitney Real Estate Partner Steven J. Wernick is featured in RentCafe article "Unlocking Miami-Dade's Housing Potential."
Day Pitney Real Estate Partner Steven J. Wernick is featured in the South Florida Business Journal article "28-Story Tower With Over 100 Apartments Planned in Miami."
Day Pitney Florida Offices Managing Partner Manuel Garcia-Linares has been appointed to chair the firm's Litigation department. The news was featured in Miami Today.
Day Pitney Alert
Day Pitney Real Estate, Environmental and Land Use practice co-chair Craig Gianetti was featured in Gothamist article "Court Tells Wealthy NJ Town: We'll Decide Where You'll Put Affordable Housing."
Day Pitney Press Release
Day Pitney Litigation Partner Mark Salah Morgan's re-election to the firm's Executive Board and appointment to vice-chair of the Litigation department was featured in NJBiz.
Day Pitney Real Estate, Environmental and Land Use Partner Steven Wernick is featured in the Miami Herald article "The End of Single-Family-Only Home Suburbs? Miami-Dade Zoning Rule Impact Could Be 'Sweeping'."
Day Pitney Real Estate Partners Nicole Magdziak and Thomas Malman represented firm client Kushner, a real estate development and management firm headquartered in New York City, on a multimillion dollar mixed use residential and retail development in the Long Branch, NJ’s Lower Broadway redevelopment zone.
Copyright © 2024 Day Pitney LLP, all rights reserved.