On Thursday, June 26, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that President Obama's 2012 recess appointments to the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") were unconstitutional. In National Labor Relations Board v. Noel Canning, 573 U.S. ____ (2014), the Court found that the President had no authority to invoke the Constitution's recess appointments clause to appoint three members to the NLRB. Ordinarily, Presidential appointees must be approved by the Senate. The recess appointments clause allows the President, without Senate approval, to "fill up all Vacancies that may happen during the Recess of the Senate, by granting Commissions which shall expire at the end of their next session." U.S. Const., Art. II, ?2, c. 2.
President Obama nominated Sharon Block, Richard Griffin and Terence Flynn to the NLRB in 2011. The nominations had been pending for some time before President Obama invoked the recess appointments clause to appoint them to the NLRB on January 4, 2012, three days after the Senate's last session. At the time of their appointments, the Senate was in a series of pro forma sessions with "no business transacted" every Tuesday through Friday from December 17, 2011, through January 20, 2012 (although the Senate enacted legislation during the pro forma sessions).
The Court interpreted the recess appointments clause "as granting the President the power to make appointments during a recess but not offering the President the authority to routinely avoid the need for Senate confirmation." The Court held that the recess appointments clause applies to both inter-session recess ("i.e., a break between formal sessions of Congress"), as well as to intrasession recess in the middle of a congressional session. The Court also held that the "scope of the words 'vacancies that may happen'" in the recess appointments clause applies to vacancies that arise during the recess and those that occurred before the recess that continue to exist during the recess. Justice Breyer, writing for the majority, found that "three days is too short a time to bring a recess within the scope of the Clause."
In New Process Steel v. National Labor Relations Board, 560 U.S. 674 (2010), the Supreme Court held that the NLRB did not have the power to act without a quorum of three members. Given this, the hundreds of decisions the NLRB issued during the recess appointments of Block, Griffin and Flynn are likely invalid.
The Court's decision sheds little light on how the NLRB should proceed with the cases issued and rules promulgated during the recess appointments. NLRB Chairman Mark Gaston Pearce issued a statement that the NLRB is "analyzing the impact that the Court's decision has on Board cases in which the January 2012 recess appointees participated."
The NLRB may take the same approach that it did following the 2010 New Process Steel decision. Following that decision, the federal courts and individual parties returned about one-fifth of the cases issued when the NLRB lacked a proper quorum (from January 2008 to March 2010) to the NLRB for new decisions. The NLRB closed the remainder of the cases "with no review required."
The NLRB currently has five members appointed with Senate confirmation. The decision is unlikely to change the NLRB's agenda.
Day Pitney Employment Attorneys Lindsey A. Viscomi, Daniel L. Schwartz and Glenn W. Dowd authored the article, "Connecticut Expands Employment Anti-Discrimination Protections," for CT Lawyer.
Day Pitney Alert "FTC Takes Historic Action Against The Enforcement of Non-Compete Agreements," was featured in the Inside Radio article, "Business Begins Angling To Scale Back FTC's Proposed Limits on Noncompete Agreements."
Chair of Day Pitney's Employment and Labor Practice Heather Weine Brochin was featured in the U.S. News & World Report article, "Should You Work 2 Remote Jobs at Once?"
Day Pitney Employment and Labor Partner Daniel Schwartz was featured in Law360 Employment Authority's article, "4 Vacation Time Tips For Employers As Year Winds Down."
Chair of Day Pitney's Employment and Labor Practice Heather Brochin and Senior Associate Jim Leva authored an article titled, "New Jersey Takes Aim at Restrictive Covenants," for the New Jersey Law Journal's Employment Law Special Section.
Rod Rodriguez and Glenn Dowd authored an article on "Minimizing litigation risk on compensation disclosure" in the July 1 edition of The Hartford Business Journal.
Day Pitney Employment and Labor Partner Rachel Gonzalez was featured in the New Jersey Law Journal’s After Hours column for being a recipient of the Executive Women of New Jersey Salute to the Policy Makers Award.
Day Pitney Employment and Labor Partner Rachel Gonzalez was featured in the Diverse Lawyers Network newsletter for being a recipient of the Executive Women of New Jersey Salute to the Policy Makers Award.
Day Pitney Press Release
Day Pitney Attorneys Daniel Schwartz, Michael Lane and Lindsey Viscomi authored the article, "Don't Be Late Paying Terminated Employees in Massachusetts," for Law360 Employment Authority.