The New York Tax Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) has just affirmed the New York Division of Tax Appeals determination that a taxpayer that signed a consent to use a test period audit methodology was bound by the consent and waived its right to a detailed audit of the entire period. In the Matter of Top Drawer Custom Cabinetry Corp., DTA No. 825588 (November 19, 2015). (See "New York Case Highlights Pitfalls of Consenting to Sampling Methodology in Tax Audit," Day Pitney Alert, February 20, 2015.)
On appeal to the Tribunal, the taxpayer contended that it had revoked its consent to use a test period audit methodology before completion of the audit. The facts, however, indicate that the Division of Taxation (Division) had substantially completed the audit on July 7, 2011, when the Division issued to the taxpayer a statement of proposed audit change setting forth the proposed deficiency resulting from the use of the test audit period. The taxpayer's request to withdraw its consent came at a meeting between representatives of the taxpayer and the Division on October 14, 2011. Based on those facts, the Tribunal determined:
We reject petitioner's [taxpayer's] claim that it validly revoked its consent to a test period audit by its representative's request for a full audit on October 14, 2011. "A waiver, to the extent that it has been executed, cannot be expunged or recalled" (Nassau Trust Co. v Montrose Concrete Prods. Corp., 56 NY2d 175, 184 [1982], rearg denied 57 NY2d 674 [1982]; see also O'Connor v Curcio, 281 AD2d 100, 103 [2001] ["a valid waiver . . . cannot be withdrawn once the parties have performed in accordance with its terms"])."
***
By substantially completing the test period audit, the Division thus executed, or performed in accordance with, the terms of the test period agreement. Under such circumstances, we agree with the Administrative Law Judge that petitioner [taxpayer] is bound by its choice to consent to the test period audit.
The Tribunal also rejected the taxpayer's contentions that the Division refused to examine or perform sample tests on other sales tax period quarters, as there was no evidence in the record to support the taxpayer's contentions.
The Tribunal's decision makes clear that a taxpayer cannot revoke a written consent to use a test period audit methodology once an audit is substantially complete. Again, this should be a reminder to carefully consider the consequences of using a test period audit methodology before signing a consent to do so with the tax authorities.
The news of Day Pitney Miami Trusts and Estates Partner Melissa Rodriguez joining the firm was featured in Law360 Pulse's article, "Private Client Atty From Akerman Joins Day Pitney in Miami."
In November 2023, Day Pitney represented an asset management firm based in Darien, CT, in connection with the formation of a private credit fund formed solely to make a multi-million dollar mortgage loan for the re-development and expansion of a brownstone located in New York, NY, the negotiation of an investment by affiliated private funds of a Rowayton, CT based investment manager, in the private credit fund, and the negotiation and closing of the mortgage loan.
The arrival of Day Pitney Trusts and Estates Partner Melissa Rodriguez to the firm’s Miami office was featured in Attorney at Law Magazine article, “Day Pitney Continues to Grow Private Client Department.”
The news of Melissa Rodriguez joining Day Pitney as a partner in the firm's Trusts and Estates practice was featured in Thomson Reuters' The Daily Docket Industry Moves column.
The arrival of Miami Trusts and Estates Partner Melissa Rodriguez was featured in the Daily Business Review article, "Day Pitney Lands Trusts & Estates Attorney from Akerman in Miami."
Day Pitney Press Release
The arrival of Miami-based Trusts and Estates Partner Melissa Rodriguez was featured in Bloomberg Law's Automation column.
In October 2023, Day Pitney represented a state pension system client in connection with a $200 million investment in a $20 billion private equity fund, and its accompanying co-investment vehicle, focused on acquiring, operating and disposing of financing, software, data and technology-enabled businesses.
Day Pitney Trusts and Estates Attorney Nikolaus Schuttauf was featured in The Wall Street Journal article titled, "The Estate Tax Catching Americans by Surprise."
Day Pitney Press Release
Copyright © 2024 Day Pitney LLP, all rights reserved.